Asian Americans in Seattle and elsewhere say they are increasingly being harassed and blamed for the COVID-19 outbreak.
By Danny R. Johnson/Political News Editor
SEATTLE – President Donald Trump has drawn significant backlash for repeatedly using the term “Chinese virus” in social media messaging and during news conferences, with experts and the public saying it perpetuates the racist association between the illness and those of Asian descent. He defended his use of the language by claiming that it was “accurate.”
The official White House Twitter account backed him up, citing previous names of illnesses like “West Nile virus” as justification. However, many officials warned against identifying the virus by location or ethnicity, including Dr. Robert Redfield, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, who agreed at a House hearing this month that it was “absolutely wrong and inappropriate” to use labels like “Chinese coronavirus,” as the illness had expanded beyond China.
Rep. Judy Chu, D-Calif., chairwoman of the Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus, told NBC News that while she welcomes the support for the community, Trump’s comments would not “be necessary if he and his supporters had not already endangered so many by spreading this toxic xenophobia.”
“For weeks, President Trump has been told by reporters, members of Congress, health experts and members of his own administration not to use the term ‘Chinese virus.’ And when confronted publicly, he rejected expert opinions and repeatedly doubled down on the term, defending it as appropriate and one he said Asian Americans would welcome. But he was wrong,” Chu said.
Other experts and officials, including Chu’s caucus, say use of the term has already resulted in a slew of attacks related to misinformation around the virus. In New York City, a 23-year-old woman was alleged to have been punched and hospitalized after another woman attacked her while invoking anti-Asian slurs. In a separate incident in California, an Asian teen was sent to the emergency room after he was bullied and assaulted because of coronavirus fears.
Asian Americans in Seattle were ringing the alarm about the potential for widespread discrimination resulting from the outbreak of the coronavirus in China, well before the virus turned deadly in King County, Washington. The nonprofit Asian Counseling and Referral Service sent out a warning after Washington’s first COVID-19 case was confirmed Jan. 21, noting that “immigrant and refugee community leaders and organizations have noticed an alarming increase in bias and harassment against our Asian American communities.”
Locally, one of the first episodes of anti-Asian sentiment to go viral happened at the big box chain Costco. In January, long before at least 24 people had died in Washington State from the virus, Devin Cabanilla and his son, who was wearing a face mask, were told to “get away” from the food samples at the Costco in Issaquah. A Costco food sample lady told the kid to get away because he may be ‘from China’ and was worrying about getting infected,” Cabanilla tweeted at the time. Cabanilla is mixed race, including white, Filipino and Chinese; his wife is Korean American.
“The painful part was hearing my 8-year-old question for the first time looking different,” Cabanilla wrote on Twitter.
“In general, Asian American people are not used to direct discrimination,” the Bellevue, Washington resident said in a recent telephone interview, noting the incident had taken his family by surprise. The company that employed the worker at Costco, Club Demonstration Services, has since apologized for the incident. Costco has also stopped handing out free samples.
But Cabanilla said he’s heard of other episodes of discrimination. Several weeks ago, a Filipino parent, Cabanilla said, was verbally attacked in Bellevue at an Amazon hub — a set of lockers where packages from the online retail giant are delivered and stored.
“That’s when I just started raising the horn about discrimination,” Cabanilla said.
Toshiko Hasegawa, executive director of the Washington State Commission on Asian Pacific American Affairs, said the discrimination has reached area schools. She received reports of students with connections to China being pulled from school. In Tacoma, students who had traveled to China were removed from dorms at Annie Wright Schools, even though the Tacoma-Pierce County Health Department had determined they had no symptoms, nor had they traveled to Wuhan, the epicenter of the coronavirus outbreak.
Hasegawa described the school’s decision as an “overstep,” while explaining that there is a fine line between discrimination and employing an “abundance of caution,” echoing a phrase many organizations have used to explain why they have canceled events.
“People are not acting out of malice; they’re acting from a place of fear,” Hasegawa said.
Joseph Lachman of the Asian Counseling and Referral Service said he doesn’t think training at schools has been consistent around the topic of discrimination. In late February, the Washington Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction provided guidance on discrimination that asked educators to remind communities “that the risk of COVID-19 is not at all connected to race, ethnicity or nationality.”
“Stigma will not help to fight the illness,” the Feb. 28 memo noted. King County and Seattle have also developed anti-stigma guidance that explicitly states that having Chinese ancestry doesn’t make an individual more vulnerable to COVID-19 and wearing a mask isn’t necessarily a sign of illness.
The county also encouraged compassion for those who have experienced bigotry and asked the public to push back on false information.
Still reports of discrimination have continued.
Steven Kim, 20, an English major at the University of Washington, said he was harassed last week while taking the light rail to school. A man sitting across from Kim, who was wearing a face mask, yelled at him about Chinese people bringing diseases to the U.S. Later that same day, another man admonished Kim for wearing a face mask near campus.
“I never thought it would actually happen here, or at least, to me,” Kim said, adding, “it’s a weird time to be Asian.”
Over the weekend at a Target store in Renton, Sameth Mell of the Coalition of immigrants, Refugees and Communities of Color, said a customer refused to go near him as he wiped down a basket. Mell said he felt the customer was treating him like a virus and responded by muttering, “Anti-Asian American sentiment is real.”
Mell said he thinks stores like Target should do more to educate the public during the outbreak.
“Renton has a large majority of Asian Americans, and if Target really wants to create a safe space, they should have signs to safely convey the messaging against prejudice and discrimination,” Mell wrote on Facebook. “I’m still pissed!”
Some members of the Asian American community said they have been portrayed as the “model minority” for so long that combating discriminatory incidents like these doesn’t always come naturally, even when victims are angry or fearful.
The model minority stereotype assumes Asian Americans are wealthier, better educated and more successful than other racial and ethnic minority groups, but that isn’t actually true, said Matthew Lee, a doctoral candidate in public health at Columbia University. Many Asian subgroups have some of the highest poverty rates, Lee said, and may not have access to the resources needed during an outbreak.
When asked why the public tends to react to disease outbreaks by lashing out at a particular community, Lee said: “I think a common reaction to public health emergencies is to find a visible and kind of useful target.”
“Pathogens aren’t visible to the eye, but racial and cultural differences certainly are,” Lee said. “It’s hard to think of a historical example where some segment of the population wasn’t unfairly treated.”
Steve Goodreau, a professor in the University of Washington Department of Anthropology who teaches a class called “Plagues and Peoples,” said that during the initial AIDS epidemic, gay men and Haitians became the easy targets. In 1900, during a bubonic plague outbreak in San Francisco, Chinese residents of Chinatown were forced to stay in their homes, but white neighbors were allowed to leave. And in medieval Europe, Jewish people were blamed for the plague and accused of purposely poisoning wells to kill Christians. Hundreds of Jews were slaughtered in an ignorant attempt to prevent the outbreak from worsening.
Asked how his Asian students are faring today during the coronavirus outbreak Goodreau said: “My sense is many of them are afraid to even talk about it.”
The stigma associated with the potentially deadly infection has also been felt elsewhere. Last week, a Vietnamese curator was excluded from an art fair in the United Kingdom because she would be “seen as carrying the virus.” In London, Jonathan Mok, a student from Singapore, was badly beaten as one his attackers shouted, “I don’t want your coronavirus in my country.” In the U.S., to the outrage of many, the University of California at Berkeley listed xenophobia as a “normal” reaction to the coronavirus. In San Francisco, merchants, residents and leaders recently took to the streets in the city’s historic Chinatown to denounce racism and bias fueled by COVID-19.
And although there has been widespread concern about the economic impact of the coronavirus, many fear Asian businesses will be particularly hard hit. Binko Bisbee, co-owner of Kobo Shop & Gallery, said her store in Capitol Hill isn’t suffering from a lack of foot traffic in the same way as her Chinatown-International District location.
Bisbee’s neighbor in the International District, Lei Ann Shiramizu, one of two owners of Momo Seattle, said although the shop has fiercely loyal customers, people are “definitely steering clear of anything associated with Asians.”
In fact, the uptick in anti-Asian bias has been so strong that the National Science Foundation has awarded a team of researchers a grant to study the pattern of discrimination during the outbreak. Charissa Cheah, a professor in the Department of Psychology at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County, plans to survey and interview Asian American families over the next year about the prejudice public health emergencies such as COVID-19 tend to reveal.
Cheah said the coronavirus seems to have refueled old stereotypes about Asian communities, including those having to do with cleanliness and questions surrounding loyalty to the U.S.
Columbia University’s Lee, for his part, said it’s hard to predict whether bigotry will grow worse as the virus becomes more widespread.